We Represent Multiple Top-Rated Carriers to Ensure You Receive Competitive Pricing and Individualized Coverage

As an independent agency, we’re not tied to just one carrier—and that’s a good thing. It means we can compare options from top-rated insurers to find the policy that fits you. From national names to regional leaders, we’ve built strong relationships with trusted providers that deliver on coverage, service, and value.

We proudly work with:

PROGRESSIVE

BILLING 1-800-876-5581
CLAIMS 1-800-274-4499

TRAVELERS

BILLING 1-800-252-2268
CLAIMS 1-800-238-6225

ORION 180

BILLING 1-866-590-3550
CLAIMS 1-866-590-3550

AAA

BILLING 1-877-840-8642
CLAIMS 1-877-840-8642

PIE

BILLING 1-844-581-0828
CLAIMS 1-844-581-0828

LIBERTY MUTUAL

BILLING 1-844-961-0334
CLAIMS 1-844-325-2467

SAFECO

BILLING 1-888-458-2246
CLAIMS 1-800-332-3226

MAIN STREET AMERICA

BILLING 1-800-258-5310
CLAIMS 1-877-425-2467

HARFORD MUTUAL

BILLING 1-800-638-3669
CLAIMS 1-800-638-3669

FRANK WINSTON CRUM

BILLING 1-866-650-4990
CLAIMS 1-888-552-6654

UTICA NATIONAL

BILLING 1-800-598-8422
CLAIMS 1-800-216-1420

HARTFORD

BILLING 1-866-467-8730
CLAIMS 1-877-805-9918

FOREMOST

BILLING 1-800-527-3905
CLAIMS 1-800-527-3907

NATIONAL GENERAL

BILLING 1-800-462-2123
CLAIMS 1-800-468-3466

CHUBB

BILLING 1-866-324-8222 # 2
CLAIMS 1-800-252-4670

What This Means for You

When you work with 1st Choice, you're not locked into a single solution. We compare options across providers, help you understand the differences, and guide you to the plan that makes sense for your budget, risk, and goals.


  • Transparent quoting across multiple providers
  • Honest recommendations—not upsells
  • Access to specialty carriers and niche policies when needed